A dog tag has one job above all others: to carry a name and a phone number, legibly, for years, on an animal who runs, swims, rolls and scratches. The metal decides how well it does that job, how it looks on the first day, and how it looks after five years. Here is how the metals we work with compare, and how to choose between them.
Which dog tag metal is best?
Choose brass if you want the classic tag: warm gold colour, durable, and a patina that deepens with age. Choose stainless steel if your dog swims or lives outdoors and you want a tag that never changes colour. Choose copper for a rich red-brown tag with the most character as it ages. Choose white bronze for a silver look without the cost of silver. Choose sterling silver when the tag is also a piece of jewelry and you are happy to polish it now and then.
| Metal | Colour | With time | Engraving | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Brass | Warm gold | Soft brown-gold patina | Hand-stamped or laser | Almost every dog |
| Copper | Rosy red | Darkens; blue-green in recesses if often wet | Hand-stamped or laser | A tag with character |
| White bronze | Pale silver | Gentle patina | Hand-stamped or laser | A silver look, everyday |
| Stainless steel | Silver-grey | Stays the same | Laser only | Swimmers, working dogs |
| Sterling silver | Bright silver | Slow tarnish, polishes back | Hand-stamped or laser | Calmer dogs, cats, keepsakes |
Is brass a good dog tag metal?
Brass is copper alloyed with zinc. It has been the metal of things meant to be handled for centuries: door fittings, instruments, buttons, tags. It is hard enough to hold a hand-stamped impression permanently and soft enough to take one cleanly. New brass is bright and golden. With water, air and wear it darkens into a soft brown-gold patina, and the stamped letters often become easier to read as the recesses darken.
Best for: almost every dog. Many of our hand-stamped designs, including The Heritage Bone Collection and The Sigil Collection, are made in it.
What is copper like on a dog tag?
Copper is one of the softer tag metals and the warmest in colour, a deep rosy red when new. It changes the most with time, moving through brown towards a darker patina, and with frequent water it can develop a blue-green bloom in the recesses. Some people love this living surface; others prefer a metal that stays put.
Best for: owners who want the tag to look old and storied, and dogs whose name deserves a warmer colour than gold.
What is white bronze?
White bronze is a pale, silver-toned copper alloy. It gives the cool colour of silver at a lower price, and it takes hand stamping well. Like brass and copper it develops a gentle patina with wear rather than staying mirror-bright.
Best for: a silver look on an everyday tag, or matching a silver collar buckle.
When is stainless steel the right choice?
Stainless steel is the hardest metal we use for tags. It does not tarnish, does not develop a patina and shrugs off sea water, lakes and muddy fields. Because it is so hard, it does not take hand stamping well, so our stainless steel tags are deep fiber-laser engraved, with the lettering cut into the metal rather than marked on its surface. You will find it as a metal choice across The Inscribed Collection, alongside brass and copper.
Best for: swimmers, farm and working dogs, and anyone who wants the tag to look the same in ten years as on the day it arrived.
Is sterling silver too soft for a dog tag?
925 sterling silver is 92.5% pure silver, the same standard as fine jewelry. It is the most precious tag metal and one of the softest, so it collects small marks from daily wear sooner than brass or steel, and it tarnishes slowly with air and moisture. Both are part of its character, and a silver cloth brings it back. Tags in The Sterling Line are solid sterling silver, for example the Skull Dog Tag at 1 mm thick.
Best for: smaller and calmer dogs, cats, and tags given as a keepsake as much as an ID.
How thick should a dog tag be?
Thin stamped blanks bend, and a bent tag is hard to read. Our tags are cut or cast from solid metal, typically between 1 and 2 mm thick. The Mighty Bone Token, made for medium and large breeds, is solid brass at 2 mm and weighs 18 grams. For small dogs a lighter tag is kinder, and for cats see The Feline Atelier.
How are the name and number put on?
On most of our tags the name on the front is hand-stamped, each letter struck into the metal one at a time, and the contact details on the back are deep fiber-laser engraved. On The Inscribed Collection the name is fiber-laser engraved too. Either way the lettering sits in the metal, not on a coating, so it does not fade. We wrote about the difference in more depth in Hand Stamping or Laser Engraving.
Does a metal tag need care?
You do not need to do anything: every metal here will stay legible without care. If you like the tag bright, rub brass, copper and white bronze with a soft polishing cloth, and silver with a silver cloth. Stainless steel only needs a rinse. Leave the patina if you like it; it is the record of the walks. For a first tag, the new puppy ID tag checklist covers size and engraving, and the Christmas gift guide for dog lovers lists tags by budget.
Dog tag metals: what owners ask
What is the best metal for a dog tag?
For most dogs, solid brass: durable, permanent for a hand-stamped name and warm in colour. Stainless steel suits dogs who swim or live outdoors. Sterling silver is the most precious and one of the softest.
Do brass dog tags tarnish?
Brass darkens into a patina. It is a surface change, not damage, and the lettering stays legible because it sits below the surface. A polishing cloth brings back the shine.
Can every metal be hand stamped?
Brass, copper, white bronze and silver can. Stainless steel is too hard, so our steel tags are deep fiber-laser engraved.
Every tag ships with a split ring for the collar. Browse all tags in Tokens for the Companion, or read our FAQ for engraving and shipping details.