Sterling Silver, Gold Plated or Solid Gold: How to Choose

Zia Sun pendant in 9K solid yellow gold

Most of our jewelry can be made in more than one way: sterling silver, oxidized silver, silver with gold or white plating, or solid gold. The design is the same; what changes is the colour, how the piece ages and what it costs. Here is what each option really is, so you can choose the one that fits how the piece will be worn.

What is sterling silver?

925 sterling silver is 92.5% pure silver alloyed with a little copper for strength. It is solid all the way through, so there is nothing to wear off. Silver tarnishes slowly with air and moisture, darkening first in the recesses of a design, which often makes the detail stand out. A silver polishing cloth brings it back to bright in a minute. Why silver has long been linked to the moon is explored in Why Fine Silver Feels Good.

Choose it for the honest colour of silver, for everyday wear, and for a piece that can be polished, repaired or re-finished for decades.

What is oxidized silver?

Oxidized silver is the same sterling silver, deliberately darkened so that the recesses are black and the raised surfaces are polished bright. It gives depth to detailed pieces such as medallions and coins. The dark finish is meant to be there, so clean oxidized pieces with a soft dry cloth and avoid abrasive polishes, which remove it.

Choose it for medallions, animals and anything with fine relief, or for a darker, older look.

How long does gold plating last?

A gold plated piece is sterling silver with a thin layer of gold bonded to its surface. It has the warm colour of gold at close to the price of silver. Plating is a surface layer, so it wears gradually wherever the piece rubs against skin, clothing or other jewelry. A pendant that hangs freely keeps its plating far longer than a ring, which is in constant contact with everything you touch. Perfume, chlorine and salt water shorten its life, so take plated pieces off to swim and put perfume on before your jewelry. Because the base is solid sterling silver, a worn piece can be re-plated rather than replaced.

Choose it for a gold look on a pendant or earrings, or to match gold you already wear.

What is white plating?

Our white option is sterling silver plated with rhodium or palladium, two bright white metals of the platinum group. You may see it called white gold plating, which is the common shop name, but the metal on the surface is rhodium or palladium, not gold. It is brighter and whiter than silver and slows tarnishing while the plating lasts. Like gold plating, it wears gradually with friction and can be renewed.

Choose it for a cool, bright white that matches platinum or white gold jewelry.

9K or 14K solid gold?

Pieces in the Solid Gold Collection are gold alloy all the way through, never plated. The karat tells you how much gold is in the alloy: 9K is 37.5% gold, 14K is 58.5% gold. 14K has a richer colour and more gold; 9K is a little harder, so it resists scratches slightly better, and costs less. Both come in yellow, rose and white gold. Gold does not tarnish, and there is no layer to wear through: a solid gold piece can be worn every day, in the shower and in the sea, for the rest of a life.

Choose it for a piece that will be worn daily and never taken off, for a piece to pass on, or for rings, which wear hardest of all. The Zia Sun and the Tree of Life are two of our solid gold pieces.

How do they compare?

Sterling silver Oxidized silver Gold or white plated Solid 9K or 14K gold
What it is Solid silver throughout Solid silver, darkened in the recesses Sterling silver with a thin surface layer Gold alloy throughout
With time Tarnishes slowly, polishes back Dark finish is meant to stay Wears gradually where it rubs Does not tarnish or wear through
Care Silver cloth Soft dry cloth only Remove for swimming and perfume None needed
Best for Everyday wear, rings Medallions and fine relief Pendants and earrings Daily wear for decades, rings, pieces to pass on

Which is best for rings, pendants and earrings?

For rings, choose sterling silver or solid gold. Plating on a ring wears fastest because a hand touches everything. For pendants and medallions, every option works; plating lasts well because a pendant hangs free. For earrings, plating lasts well too, since earrings rarely rub against anything. Find your ring size with our Ring Size Guide.

Which chain length should I choose?

Most of our necklaces come in 14, 16, 18 or 20 inches (35, 40, 45 or 50 cm), and many can also be ordered without a chain. 16 inches sits close to the base of the neck, 18 inches just below the collarbone, and 20 inches a little lower, which suits larger pendants and most men.

Silver and gold: quick answers

What is the difference between sterling silver, gold plated and solid gold jewelry?

Sterling silver is 92.5% silver, solid throughout. Gold plated is sterling silver with a thin gold layer on the surface. Solid gold is gold alloy throughout: 9K is 37.5% gold, 14K is 58.5%.

Does gold plating wear off?

Gradually, where the piece rubs. Pendants keep their plating far longer than rings. Because the base is sterling silver, it can be re-plated.

What is white plating on silver jewelry?

A thin layer of rhodium or palladium over sterling silver: brighter and whiter than silver, and slower to tarnish while it lasts.

Should I choose 9K or 14K gold?

14K has more gold and a richer colour; 9K is a little harder and costs less. Both are solid gold that will not tarnish or wear through.

Browse the full range in Jewelry for the Soul, or read the FAQ for care and shipping details. What gold and silver have meant across three thousand years is in What Do Metals Mean?