Symbol vs Sign vs Emblem: What Is the Difference?

Rampant lion medallion, the heraldic emblem, in white plated sterling silver

Three words are used almost interchangeably in ordinary language, and the interchangeability costs something. Symbol, sign, and emblem are not synonyms. They describe three fundamentally different relationships between a visible form and the meaning it carries, three different answers to the question of how a mark means what it means.

What is a sign?

A form whose meaning is set by agreement. Change the agreement and the meaning changes.

A sign points. Its relationship to its meaning is established by convention. The red octagon means stop because every jurisdiction in the relevant traffic system has agreed that it means stop. Change the convention and the sign changes with it. The philosopher Ferdinand de Saussure described this as the arbitrary nature of the sign: the relationship between the signifier, the form, and the signified, the concept, is not motivated by any natural connection between them.

What is a symbol?

A form that takes part in what it means, so its meaning cannot simply be reassigned.

A symbol participates in what it represents. Its form and meaning are not separable by convention. The spiral is the form that growth organized around a fixed center takes. It does not refer to this principle. It enacts it. Carl Jung made this distinction central to his psychology: a sign exhausts its meaning in what it points to. A symbol can never be fully exhausted. The cross has been written about for two thousand years. It has not been explained away.

What is an emblem?

A form that marks membership of a group, family or institution, and means nothing without it.

An emblem identifies. Where the sign points to a concept and the symbol participates in a reality, the emblem marks a membership. The coat of arms is an emblem. The Olympic rings are an emblem. Each identifies an affiliation. Remove the institution and the emblem becomes an arbitrary form. The Olympic rings mean nothing outside the context of the Olympic movement.

The three at a glance
Sign Symbol Emblem
What it does Points Participates Identifies
Where meaning comes from Agreement Its own form The group it marks
If the context disappears Meaning is lost Meaning remains Meaning is lost
Example A red stop sign The spiral, the Ouroboros A coat of arms, a logo

Heraldry shows the difference well: the rampant lion began as an emblem of a house, but the lion itself has symbolised courage and rule for far longer. The ancient definition is in What Is a Symbol?

Telling them apart

What is the difference between a symbol and a sign?

A sign points to its meaning by convention, and the relationship between form and meaning is assigned and can be reassigned. A symbol participates in what it represents, and its form and meaning are structurally connected and resist conventional reassignment. The red light is a sign. The Ouroboros is a symbol: its circular form enacts the cyclical principle it represents, and no convention can make it mean something else.

What is the difference between a symbol and an emblem?

An emblem identifies membership in a group, institution, or territory. Its meaning depends on the institution it marks; remove the institution and the emblem becomes an arbitrary form. A symbol carries meaning independent of any institution that uses it. The apple as a company logo is an emblem. The apple as the fruit of the tree of knowledge is a symbol.

Is a logo a symbol?

Usually not in the strict sense. Most logos are emblems — they identify a brand or institution, and their meaning exists only within the context of that brand's recognition. The distinction matters because a genuine symbol carries meaning that no institution can own or revoke.